Use the following bait to catch the fisherman.

Person                                              Bait 
--------------------------------------------------------
Fat Guy in the Orange Vest                        - Pizza
Crazy Guy                                         - Marbles
Old European Lady                                 - Moonshine
Rich Guy in the Yacht                             - Six-Pack of Beer
Skinny Guy in the Boat with the Blue Vest and Hat - Magazine
Old Guy in the Speedboat                          - Bra
Fat Guy in the Speedboat with the Red Tanktop     - Money
Bigfoot                                           - Toilet Paper or Money