Win as either team of the rivalry to unlock the corresponding trophy:

  Apple Cup: University of Washington Huskies vs. Washington State University 
  Cougars 
  Battle Of I-25 Trophy: New Mexico vs. New Mexico State 
  Bayou Bucket: Houston Cougars vs. Rice Owls 
  Beehive Boot: Utah vs. Brigham Young vs. Utah State vs. Weber State 
  Bronze Boot: Colorado State University vs. University of Wyoming 
  Commander in Chief: Army vs. Navy vs. Air Force 
  Commonwealth Cup: University of Virginia Cavaliers vs. Virginia Tech Hokies 
  Cy-Hawk Trophy: Iowa Hawkeyes vs. Iowa State Cyclones 
  Floyd Of Rosedale: University of Minnesota Gophers vs. Iowa Hawkeyes 
  Fremont Cannon: Nevada Wolf Pack vs. UNLV Rebels 
  Golden Boot: University of Arkansas Razorbacks vs. LSU Tigers 
  Golden Egg Trophy: Ole Miss Rebels vs. Mississippi State 
  Golden Hat: Texas Longhorns vs. Oklahoma Sooners 
  Governor's Cup: Kansas State vs. University of Kansas; University of Kentucky 
  vs. University of Louisville; or Florida State University vs. University of 
  Florida 
  Governor's Cup: Brown University vs. University of Rhode Island; or Georgia 
  Tech vs. University of Georgia 
  Governor's Victory Bell: Minnesota vs. Penn State 
  Illibuck: Ohio State Buckeyes vs. Illinois Fighting Illini 
  Ireland Trophy: Boston College vs. Notre Dame 
  Iron Skillet: South Methodist University Mustangs vs. Texas Christian 
  University Horned Frogs 
  Jeweled Shillelagh: Purdue vs. Nortre Dame 
  Keg of Nails: Cincinnati Bearcats vs. Louisville Cardinals 
  Land Grant Trophy: Penn State vs. Michigan State 
  Little Brown Jug: Minnesota vs. University of Michigan 
  Marching Drum: Kansas vs. Missouri 
  Megaphone: Notre Dame vs. Michigan State 
  Missouri-Nebraska Bell: Missouri vs. Nebraska 
  ODK - FOY Sportsmanship Trophy: Alabama vs. Auburn 
  Old Oaken Bucket: Indiana vs. Purdue 
  Paul Buyan Trophy: Michigan vs. Michigan State 
  Paul Buyan's Axe: Minnesota vs. Wisconsin 
  Peace Pipe: Bowling Green vs. Toledo 
  Purdue Cannon: Purdue vs. Illinois 
  Seminole War Canoe: Florida vs. Miami 
  Shellelagh Trophy: Nortre Dame vs. Purdue 
  Silver Spade: New Mexico State vs. UTEP 
  Stanford Axe: Cal vs. Stanford 
  Telephone Trophy: Iowa State vs. Missouri 
  Territorial Cup: Arizona vs. Arizona State 
  Textile Bowl Trophy: Clemson vs. NC State 
  Tiger Rag: LSU vs. Tulane 
  Victory Bell: Miami University Red Hawks vs. Cincinati Bearcats 
  Victory Bell: UCLA vs. USC 
  Victory Bell: Missouri Tigers vs. Nebraska Cornhuskers 
  Wagon Wheel: Akron vs. Kent State 
  Williams Trophy: Rice vs. Tulsa